Ballet.co Postings Pages

 Some Special Threads:
  GPDTalk about George Piper Dances ! NEW !
  NBTTalk about Northern Ballet Theatre
  SBTalk about Scottish Ballet
  ENBTalk about English National Ballet
  BRBTalk about Birmingham Royal Ballet
  TodaysLinks - worldwide daily dance links
  Ballet.co GetTogethers - meetings and drinks...

  Help on New Postings

Subject: "Munich Gala" Archived thread - Read only
  Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy     Email this topic to a friend    
Conferences What's Happening Topic #305
Reading Topic #305
Naoko S

17-10-99, 07:13 PM (GMT)
Click to EMail Naoko%20S Click to send private message to Naoko%20S Click to add this user to your buddy list  
"Munich Gala"
I had an opportunity to see a special gala performance to celebrate 10th anniversary of Bayerisches Staatsballet at Nationaltheater Munich on 9 Oct. It was my first visit to the theatre well-known for its world-acclaimed opera company. In fact, I had little knowledge on the ballet company – except that they are still very young yet has been quite active in recent years. The very reason I was there that night was to catch a glimpse of Uliana Lopatkina of Kirov amongst other international stars.

Guest stars included (in order of appearance) : Evelyn Hart/Vladimir Derevianko; Susan Jaffe/Ethan Stiefel; Uliana Lopatkina; Carlos Acosta/Aurelie Dupont; Elisabeth Platel;, Octavio Stanley Nahuelt, Igor Zelenski/Uliana Lopatkina

The gala comprised of 12 pieces – a mixture of both classics and contemporaries of which half was performed by Bayerisches Staatsballet. I must admit I couldnft adapt myself well the way the evening progressed at first; they did classical and modern pieces by turns so you had to constantly switch the mode. In any case I should be a last person to comment on modern works so here are some thoughts on classical pieces mostly done by guest artists.

When Uliana Lopatkina started Dying Swan I could barely recognize it was her. In other words the way she entered the stage was not very impressive – port de bras at the entrance, if successfully done audience could easily indulge themselves in this otherwise obvious illusion, was rather mediocre; not as eloquent as I hope them to be. Back in summer of 1997 when I first saw her in Swan Lake – the minute she entered into the scene in the 2nd act, it felt as if the entire Coliseum stopped motions. For the next twenty or so minutes I simply couldnft take my eyes off her; she was such a perfect swan I couldnft believe what I saw. Unfortunately same magic didnft work here. Two minutes is cruelly short time to recover from the initial impression – the rest of the performance didnft bring much excitement. I only wished this was not her one and only performance of the evening. Thankfully she came back later in a better shape.

It was without doubt Carlos Acosta who stole the first half of the evening. He appeared in gDiana & Actaeonh pdd. with Aurelie Dupont of POB. From the very beginning his star quality bursted; technically flawless, stage presence more than desired - but it was the elegant manner he maintained through to the end that I was impressed most. Audience applauded thunderously literally at his every movement and I was reminded what I was there for – to see outstanding performances by exceptionally gifted dancers. On the other hand, his Diana – Aurelie Dupont was unworthy partner. In short, in this pdd. she lacked both technical strength and aura of a prima ballerina. It was the second time I saw her (previously as Kitri at Garnier shortly before she was promoted to Etoile) but on both occasions I couldnft get better of her. The biggest problem it seems to me is lack of emotions and little bit of boldness – itfs as if she was too busy bothering not to make any mistake and cared mostly about the tiny details thus failed to deliver a sheer excitement, which is desired more than anything else in a ballet like Don Quixote. On stage contrast was painfully clear; he immensely enjoyed dancing and getting attentions; she looked nervous and less happy. It may be an unfamiliar partner or she may simply have not been in a good condition; in any case I expect nothing but best from Etoiles of POBc. (Incidentally another British troop –Bussell & Cooper, who were publicised to appear in a modern piece, seemed to have pulled off at the last minute. )

After intermission, my frustration for a young French Etoile was eased greatly by another French ballerina. Elisabeth Platel, who had retired from POB a few months ago opened the second half of the evening dancing The Kingdom of Shades pdd. from La Bayadere. I wouldnft call her technically intact, but she proved technicality should only come as a secondary force here after interpretation and expression of the role, to create a Spirit, that is. Her Nikiya was more feminine and human in nature than unreachable, supernatural being. It was a joy to see her dominating the stage gracefully with dignity of a true ballerina. She was partnered with Bayerishe Staatsballetfs very own Oliver Weher, who turned out to be a delight of the evening. His clean style and technical consistency was something to see. Later he stood out in the Balanchine piece where his excellent musicality was also revealed.

Climax of the evening came with dancers with pure classical style in a popular pdd. from Le Corsaire – a must-have piece for gala concerts. Kirov principals Uliana Lopatkina and Igor Zelensky displayed a classic example of 19th century ballet – as far as a style is concerned, their performance was perfect, almost triumphant - you couldnft have more than this. However I couldnft help feeling they could have added something extra more than a style to bring a life to the ballet (I know my expectations for Lopatkina was higher than a mountainc). Zelensky, who somehow reminds me of a reliable and industrious businessman who does what he is expected to do rightly, did just that. Someday I hope to see him explode on stage, giving his whole self abondoning a stoical approach. Lopatkina proved to be a most promising candidate for the inheritor of Russian balletfs centuries–old traditions; she is from head to toe an authentic classical dancer. In this pdd. I was intoxicated by her statuesque pose and flawless movement. With the next millenium nearing what I expect from her next is developing a style of her own based on the strong classical roots.

Justifiably audience gave the biggest applause for a real thing. The excitement was somewhat calmed down by the following piece of Balanchinefs Temparament, which closed the gala evening. Bayerische Staatsballet did a good job, with beautiful interepretations from some of the dancers. Nevertheless doubt remained if this abstract (and rather long) piece was a good selection to end the gala concert.

It was a magnificent sight all the dancers appeared together at the grand finale. If you regard revelence as a part of the performance then ballerinas loyal to this rule were Lopatkina and Platel – their elegant manner and grace never dissappeared through curtain calls; they looked just beautiful.

Lastly a brief note on Bayerisches Staatsballet: The company was in a pretty good shape, it seemed, one of the biggest advantage may be uniformity in physique of the dancers – Corps had a beautiful line thus the Balanchine piece escaped from being marred (at least) by aesthetic reasons. They did have strong soloists as well – besides Oliver Weher female principals were pretty good (among them was Lisa-Maree Collum – once at ENB?) and for die-hard classical roles they were armed with dancers with strong schooling background; Elena Pankova and Kirill Melnikov, both originally from Kirov.

Orchestra (Bayerische Staatsorchester) led by Andre Presser did a heavenly job; rich and smooth throughout the evening. I was filled with enormous happiness when they played Waltz from Swan Lake (for the companyfs modern piece) - I would come back to the theatre if only to listen to the orchestra.

  Printer-friendly page | Top

  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
  RE: Munich Gala Ann Williams 18-10-99 1

Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic
Ann Williams

18-10-99, 00:06 AM (GMT)
Click to EMail Ann%20Williams Click to send private message to Ann%20Williams Click to add this user to your buddy list  
1. "RE: Munich Gala"
In response to message #0
Naoko -

What a wonderful review! I really enjoyed reading it and envied your ability to pick out the strengths and weaknesses of the dancers' performances. I totally agree with your comment about Zelensky looking like a 'businessman' doing his job dutifully. I did see him, however, relaxing and having a good time dancing 'Apollo' when the Kirov were in New York in July, so perhaps there is hope for him.

  Printer-friendly page | Top

Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

Questions or problems regarding this bulletin board should be directed to Bruce Marriott